Loss of Inventory by Bankruptcy
Bankruptcy of Storage Facility Created a Compensable Loss
Plaintiffs insurers sought a declaration that there is no coverage for the insurance claim made under the policy for the loss of soybeans. The Defendants moved for partial summary judgment on its first and second counterclaim. In Endurance American Insurance Company, Zurich American Insurance Company, and, Atain Insurance Company v. Stonex Commodity Solutions, LLC F/K/A FC Stone Merchant Services, LLC, 2024 NY Slip Op 30076(U), Index No. 653234/2022, Motion Seq. No. 004, NYSCEF Doc. No. 108, Supreme Court, New York County (January 8, 2024) the Supreme Court (trial court) resolved the dispute.
BACKGROUND
From 2017 to 2021, defendant stored millions of bushels of soybeans at warehouses owned by non-party, Express Grain Terminals, LLC ("EGT"). In September 2021, upon the discovery by EGT's lender that EGT had less inventory than it was reporting, EGT was forced into bankruptcy, resulting in the dispossession from StoneX of 2,780,000 bushels of soybeans subject to a determination by the bankruptcy court of various competing interests in the disposition of EGT's assets.
Ultimately, in the bankruptcy proceedings, defendant recovered all but 502,315 bushels of soybeans. Defendant seeks coverage for the loss of these 502,315 bushels of soybeans.
SUMMARY JUDGMENT STANDARD
The proponent of a motion for summary judgment must tender sufficient evidence to show the absence of any material issue of fact and the right to entitlement to judgment as a matter of law. Courts have also recognized that summary judgment is a drastic remedy that deprives a litigant of his or her day in court. Therefore, the party opposing a motion for summary judgment is entitled to all favorable inferences that can be drawn from the evidence submitted.
DISCUSSION
In support of its motion defendant cites to the language of the insurance policy that provides that warehouse receipts, together with third-party inspection reports showing that the warehouse has sufficient goods to meet the insureds requirements, demonstrates the existence of an insurable interest.
Defendant contends that the warehouse receipts establish that EGT was in possession of the requisite number of soybeans to cover the amount of defendant's soybeans. Further, inspection reports, prepared by independent inspectors, confirm that EGT maintained the appropriate number of soybeans to satisfy defendant's stored amount. With respect to the date of the loss, defendant contends that September 2021 is the date when it became actually dispossessed based on the bankruptcy filing by EGT.
Specifically, plaintiffs contend that inspector indicating that "obligations to other depositors cannot be adequately verified [...] therefore I am unable to make any certifications on these actual obligations and their effect regarding these inventories" creates an issue of fact as to whether the soybeans for which defendant seeks coverage were in existence.
CONCLUSION
The New York Court found that defendant established an actual loss as well as an ascertainable date of the loss, September 29, 2021. The Court declined to read terms into the policy that are not there, specifically that defendant was required to ascertain whether EGT had sufficient soybeans to satisfy all receipt-holders. The parties could have contracted to include those terms in the policy but did not.
The unrefuted evidence was that there were in fact a sufficient number of bushels of soybeans to satisfy defendants claim at the time EGT filed for bankruptcy, it follows that once EGT filed for bankruptcy defendant no longer had access to the soybeans, thus triggering the date of the loss.
Defendant's motion for partial summary judgment on its first counterclaim is granted; and it is further Adjudged and Declared there is insurance coverage to cover the loss of 502,315 bushels of soybeans; and it is further Ordered that defendant's motion for summary judgment on its second counterclaim is granted; and it is further adjudged and declared that plaintiffs have breached the underlying contract between the parties for refusing to provide coverage.
ZALMA OPINION
Since the evidence showed that there were enough soybeans to cover that deposited by the defendants when EGT was forced into bankruptcy the division of the assets by the court resulted in a loss to the defendants that was not excluded from the coverages provided by the Plaintiffs.
(c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.
Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.
Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/publish/post/107007808
Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01
Go to X @bzalma; Go to the podcast Zalma On Insurance at https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/barry-zalma/support; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/c/c-262921; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg; Go to the Insurance Claims Library – http://zalma.com/blog/insurance-claims-library.
-
4:56
Barry Zalma, Inc. on Insurance Law
3 months agoProperty Investigation Checklists - 14th Edition
121 -
1:31:30
Habibi Bros.
7 hours agoThe Broletariat | Habibi Power Hour #221
30.6K2 -
2:52:50
Due Dissidence
11 hours agoDana Bash SMEARS Protesters, ORWELLIAN Speech Bill PASSES House, Columbia Fallout - w/ Prof. Zenkus
46.6K32 -
3:30:08
Melonie Mac
7 hours agoGo Boom Live Ep 2: Lara Croft Wokeover and More!
38.2K3 -
1:08:49
The Late Kick with Josh Pate
9 hours agoLate Kick Live Ep 509: Deion & Colorado | Transfer Portal Apology | Underrated Teams | CFP Issues
28.6K1 -
1:22:35
The Anthony Rogers Show
14 hours agoEpisode 304 - Let's Solve Homelessness
24.6K1 -
1:01:39
The StoneZONE with Roger Stone
10 hours agoIs Jack Smith's Appointment Even Legal? Trump Impeachment Lawyer David Schoen Enters The StoneZONE!
46.3K21 -
1:07:02
Donald Trump Jr.
13 hours agoBiden Moves US Closer to a Military Draft, Ric Grenell Explains Why, Plus the Jack Smith Scandal You Haven’t Heard About | TRIGGERED Ep.133
122K152 -
1:42:45
The Quartering
10 hours agoThe Bible Now Illegal In America, Another Boeing Whistleblower Disappears, Hero College Bros
82.8K81 -
50:08
Kimberly Guilfoyle
13 hours agoSPIES, LIES, AND DEEP STATE CRIMES: CIA Spying Scandal, Plus the Swamp’s Gaza Refugee Disaster, Live with Rep Matt Gaetz and Russ Vought | Ep. 122
77.8K80