Thales and the Origin of Western Philosophy
In this video, I explore the philosophy of Thales, a philosopher whom many believe to have inaugurated the Western philosophical tradition. Most contemporary accounts of Thales portray him as cutting ties to Greece's mythological past and instead adopting a thoroughly naturalistic and empirical approach to reality, an approach that is said to characterize the whole of Western philosophy. In this video, I contend that this naturalistic picture of Thales is misguided and substantially outstrips our available historical evidence. First, I show how this interpretation requires a naïve appropriation of Aristotle's assertions concerning Thales. When we look at Aristotle's account in context, we can see that he isn't so much trying to articulate an objective historical account of previous philosophers as he is trying to set forth a whigish history of philosophy that culminates in his own metaphysics. Second, I demonstrate that contemporary interpreters also ignore Aristotle's observations that Thales account parallels the mythological accounts of Homer and Hesiod. Third, I show that the contemporary view ignores the animistic implications of Thales claim that "all things are full of gods" and I argue against a Spinozistic interpretation of Thales' assertion. Fourth, I show that even the standard anecdotal stories about Thales life are more ambiguous than the naturalistic interpretation would have us believe. And finally, I argue that Goethe offers a better myth of Thales than the current naturalistic myth by examining the Classical Walpurgis Night scene in Faust Part 2.
A corresponding essay can be found here:
https://premieretat.com/beyond-naturalism-demythologizing-thales/
The images used in this video are in the public domain.
-
2:22:40
Jewels Jones Live ®
1 day agoTHE ART OF LAWFARE | A Political Rendezvous - Ep. 79
9.24K25 -
25:30
Stephen Gardner
19 hours ago🔴BREAKING: Trump MISTRIAL details | George Clooney's Netanyahu SECRET LEAKS!!
23.8K288 -
1:18:43
Kim Iversen
20 hours agoAmbassador Chas Freeman "Israel Has Never Put Forward A Peace Proposal"
44.7K87 -
48:34
Breaking Points
2 days agoMAGA Lawyer DEBATES Liberal Analyst On Trump Legal Cases
17.4K22 -
19:09
Scammer Payback
4 days agoConfronting Scammer Payback Imposters
73K25 -
9:07
shaneyyricch
23 hours agoAddressing my beef with Harry Sisson
55.4K96 -
1:52:46
Game On!
18 hours agoBoston Celtics Can't Win Game 2! | Sports Morning Espresso Shot
41.8K33 -
1:00:01
Trumpet Daily
1 day agoMarxist Left Continues to Imprison Trump’s Inner Circle - Trumpet Daily | June 7, 2024
38.1K56 -
LIVE
The Amber May Show
11 hours agoReAwaken America Tour Detroit, MI - DAY 2 | Join General Flynn, Eric Trump, Kash Patel, Mayor Giuliani & Team America + Request Tickets for October 18-19 Selma, NC At: TimeToFreeAmerica.com
1,462 watching -
12:23
Freakin' Reviews
1 day agoRice Robot Review: One-Touch Rice Cooker? | As Seen on TV
73.8K30